A strict diet puts your brain on alert because your body reads a shortage of food as a threat. The response is more hunger, more thoughts about food and more stress, and that makes sticking to it harder, not easier. So it is not about your willpower, but about how your body is built.
Many women who come to me have dozens of diets behind them and think they 'just can't do it'. This blog shows what research says, so you can let go of that feeling.
What happens in your brain when you diet strictly?
The best-known study is the Minnesota starvation experiment from the 1940s by Ancel Keys. Healthy men got about half of their normal food for months. They became more and more preoccupied with food, thought about it all day and ate far more than normal afterwards. Your brain is trying to make sure you get enough.
Why do hunger and cravings increase?
After weight loss, the hormones that regulate hunger and fullness change. In a study by Sumithran et al., these changes were still present a year after a strict diet, in a direction that makes you hungrier. Your body is trying to get the lost weight back.
Does dieting also stress you out?
It seems so. In a study by Tomiyama et al., women who strictly restricted calories for three weeks had higher cortisol levels and reported more stress than women who did not. You can read more about cortisol in stress, cortisol and cravings.
Why does strict dieting often lead to a binge?
Research by Stice et al. showed that fasting and strict dieting increase the risk of developing binge eating later on. Strict rules and 'forbidden' foods make the craving stronger. That is how the familiar cycle of being strict, breaking and feeling guilty arises.
| Strict diet | Calmer approach |
|---|---|
| Big deficits, short time | Small steps, long time |
| Forbidden foods | Everything is allowed, with attention |
| Skipping meals | Eating regularly, enough protein |
| Focus on the scale | Focus on habits and thoughts |
What works instead?
Give your body enough food, eat regularly and choose a calm pace. Make sure you get enough protein, sleep and movement, and work on the thoughts and habits underneath your eating behaviour. That last part is why my coaching programme lasts 6 months: breaking patterns takes time. Read why 12 weeks is not enough and why willpower does not work. An overview is in the weight loss coach guide.
Would you like someone to look along with you?
On 1-on-1 coaching you leave your details and Fleur will call you.
Frequently asked questions
Why do I crave more when I diet?
Your body reads a shortage of food as a threat and therefore increases hunger and thoughts about food. That is a normal response, not a lack of willpower.
Is a strict diet bad for you?
A strict diet is hard to keep up for many people and can feed stress and binge eating. If in doubt, talk to your GP or dietitian.
What is a better way to lose weight?
A calm pace with regular eating, enough protein and attention to thoughts and habits. Support can help with that.
Sources: Keys et al. (1950), The Biology of Human Starvation; Sumithran et al. (2011), Long-term persistence of hormonal adaptations to weight loss, New England Journal of Medicine; Tomiyama et al. (2010), Low calorie dieting increases cortisol, Psychosomatic Medicine; Stice et al. (2008), Fasting increases risk for onset of binge eating and bulimic pathology, Journal of Abnormal Psychology.
So I am going to help you.
About the author: Fajah Lourens is the founder of Killerbody (since 2015), has written books that have sold 350,000 copies in total, and is an NLP practitioner.
